The City Council of Lewiston, Maine, convened on October 7, 2025, to discuss a significant proposal regarding the police department's firearms. The primary agenda item was the authorization to use asset forfeiture funds to purchase 94 Walther PDP pistols, intended to replace the current SIG Sauer P320 pistols, which have raised safety concerns due to accidental discharges.

Interim Chief Higgins presented the case for the new firearms, citing research indicating that the SIG Sauer P320 has been prone to accidental discharges without trigger pulls. He emphasized the urgency of replacing these weapons, noting that many police departments across the country are moving away from this model. The department plans to expedite training with the new firearms to ensure officers can qualify with them promptly.

Councilor Herrmann raised concerns about the potential liability of selling the current defective firearms to a federal firearms dealer. Chief Higgins clarified that while the manufacturer has not acknowledged defects or offered a buyback program, the department could receive approximately $18,000 from the trade-in. However, there is a risk that holding onto the firearms could yield a higher return if a class action lawsuit results in a settlement.

Several council members expressed their support for the immediate sale of the SIG Sauer pistols, citing safety concerns and the unpredictability of future reimbursements. Councilor Longchamps and Councilor Grant both voiced their preference for securing the $18,000 now rather than risking a prolonged wait for potential refunds.

Public comments during the meeting reflected a mix of opinions. Some residents supported the immediate purchase of the Walther pistols, while others suggested exploring the possibility of a free upgrade program from SIG Sauer for the existing firearms. However, the consensus among council members leaned towards proceeding with the purchase of the new pistols to ensure officer safety and community trust.

The council ultimately decided to move forward with the proposal, emphasizing the importance of addressing the safety issues associated with the current firearms. The meeting concluded with a clear directive to prioritize the well-being of both police officers and the community they serve.