The Historic Review Commission referred a proposal for a two‑story, ~1,600‑square‑foot accessory structure at 932 Portnet Street (case 2-2025-250) to the Design Review Committee (DRC) for further work on Oct. 15, 2025.

The applicant said the goal was to create two rental units on a large lot and to add parking; commissioners and staff raised concerns that the proposed footprint and two‑story massing would represent roughly 72% of the main building’s footprint and would exceed the 40% guideline cited in the staff report. Neighbors and the Dignity Hill/Dignuedy Hill association expressed concern in submitted voicemail and letter materials.

Why it matters: The commission said the design as presented does not align with historic‑district massing guidance and needs clarification about property lines, entry alignment and parking solutions before it could be approved. Commissioners suggested the applicant meet with staff and neighborhood representatives and return with a DRC review that clarifies compliance issues.

Action: The commission voted to refer the proposal to DRC so the applicant could provide clearer site plans, massing studies and alternatives that meet the 40% guideline or explain why a different approach is warranted. The motion to send the case to DRC passed unanimously on the roll call. Commissioners urged the applicant to consult zoning staff and neighborhood representatives before return.