Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Noise Ordinance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Germantown trustees debate noise rules; no ordinance change adopted
Summary
Trustees reviewed complaints about early-morning lawn mowing and considered whether to adopt an objective decibel standard, but did not adopt changes. Staff agreed to pull and categorize noise-complaint records for further review.
Germantown trustees discussed two noise-related issues — early-morning use of outdoor power equipment and whether the village should shift from a subjective “reasonableness” standard to an objective decibel limit — and did not adopt any code changes during the meeting.
Trustees heard that the village’s residential code currently allows use of outdoor lawn equipment starting at 6 a.m. Some trustees said they would consider moving residential lawn-equipment start times in line with commercial limits (for example, 7 a.m. weekdays and 8 a.m. weekends). Police and fire staff told trustees the village receives only a handful of lawn-mowing complaints each year, and that most noise complaints come from bars and seasonal festivals.
Village legal staff reported a survey of 43 municipalities showing 30 use a subjective reasonableness standard for noise, eight use a single fixed decibel standard and four use mixed approaches. Legal counsel noted that while courts increasingly accept scientific instruments, enforcement using a decibel meter would still require foundation testimony about equipment calibration and operator training (similar to radar or breathalyzer evidence). That creates administrative training and certification requirements for officers or staff and may still leave weather- and site-dependent measurement questions (for example, where to measure and how ambient conditions affect readings).
Chief Delaney, who answered technical questions about calls and measurement limitations, explained decibel readings are influenced by atmospheric conditions and require calibration and consistent procedures. Several trustees expressed reluctance to require widespread officer training and certification to operate sound meters given the low number of lawn-mowing complaints. Trustee Pieper requested that staff pull and manually categorize noise-complaint records for the past two years, including bar-related complaints and other sources, to establish the magnitude of the problem before changing the code.
No ordinance amendments were introduced or voted on at the meeting. Trustees discussed possible next steps, including asking staff to draft proposed language if the board wanted to pursue an objective standard (fixed decibel or above-background limits) or to change allowable times for residential outdoor equipment. Staff indicated they can compile past noise complaints manually and provide that data for a future meeting.
