Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Surplus Vehicle Donation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council questions proposal to donate surplus ambulance to sister city Cananea amid budget concerns
Summary
City staff proposed donating a decommissioned Ford E-450 ambulance to Sierra Vista's sister city Cananea and estimated its residual value at $10,000–$15,000; multiple council members asked whether auctioning the vehicle would recoup taxpayer funds and sought details about fleet replacement practices.
City staff presented a proposal Wednesday to donate a decommissioned ambulance to Sierra Vista’s sister city, Cananea, Mexico, and council members raised questions about the fiscal tradeoffs of donating equipment with estimated residual value.
Helen Lee, chief procurement officer, told the council the surplus vehicle is a decommissioned Ford E-450 ambulance (model year described in staff materials as 2009) that the city had already replaced. ‘‘We have a great working relationship with our sister city, Cananea. We have identified this particular vehicle as a good candidate for donation to them,’’ Lee said. She estimated the ambulance’s surplus value at ‘‘probably between $10,000 and $15,000’’ if sold at surplus.
Councilmember Myers pressed staff on the choice to donate rather than sell, asking, ‘‘are we in a position now where we feel comfortable that we can just give 10 to $15,000 away like that?’’ Myers noted he was concerned about foregone revenue amid a period of declining city revenue. Lee and Assistant City Manager Yarbrough replied that the vehicle had been taken out of service because the rear suspension required manual cranking and that fleet replacement follows a schedule set by Public Works and by useful-life determinations.
Yarbrough said the city has a long-standing practice of donating surplus vehicles to Cananea and cited prior donations, including a recent batch in 2023 when eight vehicles and other equipment were donated. He said the donated vehicles have been put into regular use by Cananea and described the transfers as a goodwill practice supported by past councils. Staff also said that one vehicle in a prior donation could not be accepted by Cananea and was sent to auction.
Council members asked operational questions about the donation. Staff confirmed that once ownership transfers to Cananea, the city cannot control what Cananea does with the vehicle; Cananea could, in principle, auction the vehicle after receiving it. Staff noted that donations are discretionary and that the council has the authority to approve or reject the transfer. No final vote or formal approval to donate was recorded in the transcript of this meeting.
Staff also provided fleet context: the ambulance being proposed for donation had been scheduled for replacement earlier this year; the fire department maintains reserve ambulances; and ambulances can take nearly two years to order and receive. Those operational factors were cited by staff in explaining why vehicles are kept in service until they reach the end of their useful life rather than retired earlier for auction.
No formal decision was recorded during the discussion; staff said the matter is presented as a resolution (Resolution 2025072) and has been customary in prior years, and the council may decide whether to proceed with the donation.
