The Historic Review Board on Aug. 12 approved application 2025‑787202 (202 West Park) for replacement of an aged painted metal roof with a 26‑gauge double‑lock standing seam Galvalume roof and a double‑lock ridge. The applicant, Linda Anderson of Derbysheep Mellon Roofing Incorporated, told the board the existing red painted 5‑V crimp roof had corroded; the proposed Galvalume product is not a painted enamel finish but a long‑lasting galvanized‑aluminum alloy that will weather to a pewter tone rather than a bright, baked‑on color.

Staff reviewed the proposal against the roof and roof‑features guideline (section 3.23) and recommended approval while asking the board to carefully consider the cornice/collar details because the new material and ridge profile would differ from the existing painted surface. Board members asked about shine and aging: staff and the applicant explained Galvalume oxidizes to a pewter tone and typically holds its appearance longer than older galvanized products and that a painted, baked‑on enamel finish would have a glossier surface.

Action
The board approved the COA as presented. Staff reminded the applicant and owner that required permits must still be obtained for work.

Why it matters
The decision reflects a common preservation tradeoff: replacing an older painted metal roof with a modern metal alloy that closely approximates historic profiles while offering greater longevity. The board specifically considered material finish, aging behavior and visual compatibility with adjacent historic properties.

Follow up
Applicant expects to schedule work in September upon receipt of permits.