Commission approves enclosed porch rehabilitation at 312 North Fifth Street, opts for siding over blind windows

The Geneva Historic Preservation Commission on Aug. 19 approved a proposal to rehabilitate an enclosed front porch at 312 North Fifth Street and to move the entry door slightly for improved interior layout. Staff provided a detailed history: the property contains multiple historic phases including an 1845 workers cottage and a Greek Revival section from the 1850s. The current porch enclosure dates from mid‑20th century alterations and is clad in vinyl; staff and the applicant removed sections of siding during review and found no historic siding beneath. The applicants, Daniel Bowering and partner, explained they have already repaired or replaced many exterior elements and want to convert the enclosed porch to a usable conditioned interior space. They proposed two options: a preferred submission using Hardie lap and vertical panels with trimmed openings, or an alternate that would retain 'blind windows' (false window elements) to maintain the existing window rhythm. Commission discussion revisited a split view from a prior concept review. Commissioners who spoke noted the existing windows appear to be nonhistoric (aluminum sliders likely from the 1960s) and are at or near the end of their useful life. Several commissioners preferred the siding option over blind windows for visual coherence and interior functionality. The commission voted to approve the preferred submission with roll call recording all present commissioners voting yes. The approved work includes rehabilitation of the porch enclosure with specified Hardie siding, adjustment of the front door location to improve interior circulation, and replacement of failing window units; the applicants plan to coordinate matching trim, color, and suitable siding profile with staff.