Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Ethics And Conduct topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Robert Malone sworn; senators debate whether his social‑media memes crossed a line after CDC shooting
Summary
Dr. Robert Malone, a new ACIP appointee, was sworn and defended meme posts compiled on a Substack; senators including Richard Blumenthal and others said some posts were threatening and inappropriate after a deadly shooting at CDC, while Malone said the items were humor and not intended to incite violence.
The hearing turned to conduct and public communications by members of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s advisory committee on immunization practices after senators raised social‑media posts by Dr. Robert Malone.
Senator Richard Blumenthal opened by characterizing some posts as threatening and asked the chairman to enter letters and evidence into the record. Blumenthal said a social‑media image posted by Malone — an image of a revolver with a one‑bullet motif that had circulated hours before a gunman fired rounds at the CDC — was an example of rhetoric that could inflame violence. "When someone advising CDC on vaccine policy asks where in the world officials are hiding after a deadly attack, that crosses every line," Blumenthal said.
Malone, who was sworn and later testified, told the committee the items were part of a Friday/Sunday meme roundup published on his Substack, Malone.News, and that he and his wife compile images from other sources for commentary. "Russian roulette is a metaphor," Malone said in his testimony. He told the panel the meme collection was intended as political satire and humor, not an incitement to violence, and said he had not advocated violence. Malone said he had previously provided his CV to the committee and offered to meet with Senate staff to discuss qualifications after hearing Blumenthal say Malone was unqualified.
Senators and witnesses also highlighted the context of threats against public health workers. Senator Blumenthal and other witnesses described a wider pattern: JAMA and other outlets had reported threats to physicians and public health officials after pandemic disputes, and a recent open letter by more than 1,000 current and former HHS employees called for the resignation of HHS leadership. At the same time, members of the panel said threatening rhetoric should be condemned; Malone agreed that targeted violent threats are unacceptable.
The committee did not take formal disciplinary action. Blumenthal asked the chairman to join a demand that Malone be fired from advisory roles; the chairman and others took no administrative action on the record during the hearing.
Ending — Malone remained a sworn witness and defended the posts as metaphors and satire. Senators emphasized the need to separate robust public debate from rhetoric that could endanger public servants, and several members said threats against scientists and public health workers are unacceptable.
