Commission approves stoop gate for 66 Perry Street after residents cite tourism and safety concerns

The Landmarks Preservation Commission approved a proposal to install a decorative metal stoop gate at 66 Perry Street in the Greenwich Village Historic District after residents, preservation groups and neighborhood board members testified in favor of the measure.

Owner Barbara Lorber described longstanding problems caused by frequent tourist activity — including people climbing the stoop and affecting resident privacy and safety — and said the gate is intended to protect three households and the building’s fabric. Architect Izzy Cruz said the gate’s arched form echoes the building’s pediment and window arches and that the design was selected to harmonize with the restored stoop and existing ironwork. Village Preservation and the Victorian Society of New York both testified in support; Village Preservation called the proposed gate “harmonious with the existing ironwork.” Neighbors testified the site has become a tourist magnet and that chains and signs have not prevented intrusions.

Commissioners agreed the block’s variety of stoops and area-way conditions made a one-off gate acceptable. Several commissioners recommended simplification of the arch and close staff review of hinge and anchoring details so the gate does not damage the restored newel or historic rail. Commissioner Lutfi described the owner’s maintenance and said the gate design “does a very good job of tying in with what exists.” The commission approved the gate with the condition that the applicant work with staff to simplify and refine details. The vote was eight in favor, none opposed.