Commission approves historic-style entrance infill at Pickwick House, West Village
Loading...
Summary
The Landmarks Preservation Commission approved wood multilite entrance infill and package cabinetry at Pickwick House (constructed 1886) after applicants presented historic documentation and community support; the commission noted ADA constraints.
The Landmarks Preservation Commission on March 25 approved a plan to replace the central entrance infill at Pickwick House, an 1886 loft building in the Greenwich Village Historic District, returning the bay to painted wood multilite doors and sidelights.
The commission voted unanimously (9–0) to approve LPC 24‑11872 for 233 (commonly known as Pickwick House) Bethune Street. Commissioner Master moved for approval and Commissioner Jefferson seconded.
What was proposed: The applicant’s team, represented by Charles Henkles and Scott Cooper, presented historical research and comparative examples to justify recreating heavy wood doors, multilite transoms and package cabinetry below the glazing. The design calls for painted wood, multilite doors set within existing cast-iron storefront surrounds and American walnut cabinetry behind the glazing to serve as package-storage lockers with key-fob control.
Community response and access issues: The Historic Districts Council and Manhattan Community Board 2 both supported the proposal; the community board recommended the applicant reconsider incorporating permanent ADA access but acknowledged the project retained existing exterior steps and that the owners will use a portable ramp as needed. The applicant said the building currently has no disabled residents and that a permanent accessibility alteration would be difficult without altering the historic grade and steps.
Commission comments: Commissioners praised the research and sensitive replication of historic elements, noting the proposed 8‑foot door height to accommodate moving furniture and to reflect the building’s historic commercial loading function. The commission found the proposed dark‑green finish appropriate to harmonize with the existing storefront and cornice.
Next steps: Approval was unanimous; work will proceed under LPC permit requirements and the applicant should work with staff if future code or accessibility modifications are needed.
