Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Accessibility In Landmarks topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
LPC approves barrier‑free lift at 432 Lafayette Street, citing minimal intrusion
Summary
The Landmarks Preservation Commission voted 8–0 May 6 to approve installation of a barrier‑free sidewalk lift and related cellar opening at 432 Lafayette Street (LPC 25‑09295), finding the proposed metal and glass lift set below the first‑floor windows would minimize visual impact on the Greek Revival LaGrange Terrace facade.
The Landmarks Preservation Commission on May 6 approved a proposal to install a barrier‑free platform lift and to modify a cellar opening at 432 Lafayette Street in the NoHo Historic District, part of the LaGrange Terrace group of Greek Revival townhouses (LPC 25‑09295). The roll call vote was 8–0.
Scope and precedent: The applicant sought permission to remove an existing cellar window and infill and to install a sidewalk lift that would provide at‑grade access to the basement level. The project uses the same lift design and finish previously approved for a nearby townhouse at 428 Lafayette, and staff said the proposed finish would be an off‑white cream color to blend with the building base and minimize visual intrusion.
Public comment and preservation concerns: Christina Conroy of the Victorian Society criticized the design as bulky and urged exploration of more transparent or retractable lift models. LPC staff and commissioners responded that the site’s historic ground‑floor conditions vary along Lafayette and that the lift design proposed here is the least intrusive practical option for the existing basement entry conditions; commissioners noted that earlier approvals and the building’s altered base limited ramp alternatives.
Commission rationale: Commissioners who spoke said a ramp was infeasible given the site’s geometry and that the proposed platform lift, set below the first‑floor window line and finished to match the stone base, is an appropriate, reversible intervention to provide accessibility. The National Trust for Historic Preservation — which holds an easement on the property — and local boards were noted in the record and the applicant said they had received National Register approval as well.
Outcome: LPC approved the installation with a condition that the lift’s finish match the approved cream-colored base and that sidewalk, retaining wall and repair work protect existing historic vault walls during installation. The work will be permitted following submission of final construction details.
