Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Settlement Edge Homes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
RDA and city approve $230,000 settlement with Edge Homes over Vineyard Lakefront work; board withholds $290,000 for unfinished items
Summary
After a closed-session legal strategy discussion, the RDA board and city council approved a settlement with Edge Homes that pays the developer $230,000 under a 2021 reimbursement agreement and reserves roughly $290,000 for the city to complete unfinished landscaping and grading; the motion passed by roll call vote.
Vineyard — The Redevelopment Agency and the city approved a settlement on Feb. 26 to resolve disputes with Edge Homes over infrastructure and landscaping at the Lakefront (Vineyard Shores) development. After a closed-session strategy discussion on pending litigation, the board voted to pay Edge Homes $230,000 under a 2021 reimbursement agreement and to reserve approximately $290,000 of the remaining funds for the city to complete unfinished work.
City legal counsel Jamie introduced the matter in open session, saying the parties had a disagreement over what work was completed under the 2021 reimbursement agreement and over entitlement-related claims, including a developer assertion that the city owed nearly $900,000 for road-width costs. Jamie explained the settlement was a negotiated resolution intended to provide the city with resources to finish the remaining landscaping and grading without continuing larger, costlier litigation. “We needed to come to some resolution that would allow the city to have some resources to move forward with the work and would allow us to separate from Edge Homes in that reimbursement agreement,” Jamie said.
Under the 2021 agreement, Edge Homes could have received reimbursements not to exceed $647,000, disbursed in partial payments (roughly $129,000 per year in the original payment schedule, Jamie said). City staff said there remained a reimbursable balance just under $520,000 before the settlement. The negotiated settlement pays Edge Homes $230,000 and leaves the city/RDA holding roughly $290,000 to apply to the unfinished landscaping and grading.
Board members and residents raised concerns about the pace of work, prior marketing and plat language about road ownership and the community’s experience with unfinished trail and landscape areas. Several board members said the reimbursement agreement lacked sufficient detail about work scopes, acceptance criteria and remedies, and they urged clearer contract terms going forward. Jamie recommended settling to avoid two larger disputes — the reimbursement-balance claim and a separate entitlement/exaction claim — that could be far more expensive to litigate.
The motion to approve the settlement passed on roll call: Jake — aye; Brett — aye; Sarah — aye; Dara — aye; Marty — excused. The RDA board chair said the settlement will allow staff to use the reserved funds to advance completion and then seek public input on design and timing for the remaining landscaping.
Votes at a glance: the board approved the settlement agreement (payment of $230,000 to Edge Homes; $290,000 reserved to the city/RDA for unfinished work). The meeting also approved routine consent items earlier in the agenda by voice vote.
What’s next: city staff will determine how to use the reserved funds to finish landscaping and grading and will present plans and a public process for community input; the board did not direct immediate litigation or additional payments at the meeting.
