Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Collection Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Trustees discuss youth-room content and complaints process; graphic novels moved to adult stacks
Summary
Trustees discussed whether material placed in the young-adult room should be limited by an equivalent movie rating and reviewed the library’s complaint procedure; the board said professional reviews guide acquisitions and confirmed that previously challenged graphic novels have been moved to the adult section.
Trustees at the Franklin Township Public Library Board of Trustees meeting on Jan. 22 debated whether books placed in the young-adult room should be limited to content equivalent to a PG-13 rating and reviewed the library’s existing processes for handling complaints about materials.
The discussion noted that books do not carry standardized movie-style ratings and that librarians generally acquire materials based on professional reviews. Trustee Kevin McNeil said purchases are driven by professional review outlets used by libraries: "The books that we buy here are all from professional reviews in library journals," he said, explaining the acquisition process for adult and young-adult materials.
Trustees discussed a recent complaint brought by a resident about material that had previously been located in the youth area. Staff reported that some graphic novels and manga that drew concern were moved from the young-adult room into the adult stacks following earlier review. The board described an existing complaint process: patrons can submit a complaint form and the matter is referred to a review committee.
Board members emphasized practical limits. Trustees noted that, unlike films, books lack a single, universally applied rating system, and that readers of different ages and backgrounds interpret text differently. Several trustees said parental involvement and the library’s existing complaint-review procedures are the appropriate first steps rather than wholesale new restrictions.
The board did not adopt a new written restriction tying placement in the young-adult room to an equivalent movie rating. Trustees instead affirmed that selection rests with professional staff, that contested items can be referred via the complaint form and committee, and that staff will continue to exercise professional judgment when assigning materials to the young-adult area.
Ending: trustees agreed the topic bears continued attention and invited any resident with a specific concern to file the formal complaint form so staff and the review committee can evaluate the item in full context.
