Board grants permit for repairs and replacements on Sisters Island property; short-term rental use discussed

Hopatcong Planning Board members approved a replacement and repair application for a property on Sisters Island (Lot 50415, Lot 13) presented by Devon Ramm Sundar. The work includes replacing an existing hot tub and repairs to a boathouse and associated structures; applicants said the work is a like-for-like replacement within 50 feet of the lake.

The borough’s engineer letter included a short checklist of items the applicant must meet; the applicant indicated willingness to comply. Board members and staff discussed the potential regulatory consequences if the property were to be used as a short-term rental: staff noted that certifying two dwellings or using the property as two homes could trigger additional notice and permit requirements. The applicant said the property is not currently advertised on Airbnb and that prior online photos date to earlier ownership, not current rental listings.

The application was opened to the public; no objections were recorded in the meeting transcript. The board moved and seconded approval and recorded affirmative votes from members present. The board closed the item by reminding the applicant to address small engineering comments and to consult municipal staff if a future change in use (short-term rental) is contemplated.

Ending: The board approved the replacement work with conditions from the borough engineer and advised the applicant to consult staff regarding any future change in rental status that would affect municipal notice or permitting requirements.