Wilmington council authorizes outside legal counsel after public calls for independent review

Wilmington City Council voted unanimously Tuesday to authorize hiring outside legal counsel after a night of public comment in which residents urged an independent review of allegations involving the mayor and actions by city administration.

The vote came when Council suspended rules and passed Resolution 25-25, “authorizing Wilmington city council to hire additional legal counsel,” on a 7-0 roll call. The motion was made by Councilman Wells and seconded by Councilman Osborne.

The matter drew repeated public comment. Elaine Silverstrom, a resident of 71 Rita Place, told the council, “I rise out of deep concern as a resident of Wilmington,” and called for an “independent review board” and suggested the mayor consider administrative leave if applicable. Jason Stoops, who said his business was the subject of a city legal effort last year, asked for review “by a neutral outside agency” and accused the administration of targeting businesses and nonprofits.

Kelsey Swindler thanked council members who had engaged with community groups and asked the council to “take these allegations seriously and support further investigation.” Nick McCabe, who identified himself as a local chess coach, and Quintin Koger (who spoke about personal family loss connected to addiction) also urged council to act to restore trust.

Mayor Patrick Haley addressed the chamber after public comment and said he was willing to provide documentation to answer questions. “I would like to have that opportunity rather than being condemned for some things I haven't done,” Mayor Patrick Haley said, and urged that questions be resolved through a process that protects confidentiality where required.

Council members who moved and seconded the resolution said the intent was to ensure council had independent legal advice available while questions and public concerns are addressed. The resolution was passed as an emergency measure; Council President (presiding officer) announced that the council would keep members updated ahead of the next meeting in early June.

The public comments and the council’s action followed earlier remarks at the meeting alleging a culture of distrust in city administration and specific claims about interactions with Sugar Tree Ministries and the Wilmington Safety Association. Several speakers asked for transparency, due process, and for an outside review to restore public confidence.

The resolution does not itself open an investigation; it authorizes council to retain additional legal counsel. Council did not specify a firm or a scope of work in the meeting minutes; those details were described as to be reported at a later date.