Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Works topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves City Hall fountain upgrades and fencing after debate over public access
Summary
After commissioners and staff debated vandalism, visibility and public-access concerns, the commission approved renovations to the City Hall fountain area including an exterior fence to be locked outside business hours. Vote: 4–1.
The Sarasota City Commission on Feb. 18 approved upgrades to the City Hall fountain and surrounding plaza, which include removal and replacement of deteriorated stonework, electrical upgrades and an exterior fence to secure the area at night.
City facility manager Eric Patrick told commissioners the fence was proposed after repeated vandalism and sanitation problems in the area, and said anchors and concrete tables had been installed previously to curb theft and damage. "The idea behind that was they couldn't really remove it and damage it," Patrick said, explaining past decisions on site furniture. He also said the gates could be left open during business hours and locked at night.
Deputy City Manager Pat Robinson and Development Services Director Lucia Panaca described frequent calls for service to that corner of the City Hall campus and said lighting and improved sightlines could also reduce illicit activity. "Generally, the vandalism is happening in the evenings," Robinson said, and staff offered alternatives such as cameras and improved lighting if the commission preferred to avoid a fence.
Some commissioners stressed philosophical concerns about fencing public land. Commissioner Ahern Koch said the Jack West–designed City Hall campus was intended to be accessible and that a fence would "send the wrong message." Commissioner Batty and others countered that repeated bathing in the fountain and sanitation problems made security measures necessary to protect public health; Batty said he had seen people sleeping in the fountain area late at night.
The commission approved the full upgrade package, including the fence, with a 4–1 vote. Commissioners agreed the gates should be open during regular business hours. The motion tied final design and timing to the construction bid presented in the consent item. Commissioner Ahern Koch voted against the fence, arguing staff should first try lighting and sight-line improvements and avoid fencing public space unless necessary.
What the vote does and does not do: The contract award/upgrade authorization allows project work to proceed per the bid packet discussed in the consent item; the fence element was included by commission direction and can be left unlocked during the day and locked at night as a matter of operations.
