Historic commission approves after-the-fact porch repairs at North Grant Street property

The Bay City Historic District Commission on April 9 approved a certificate of appropriateness for porch repairs that had already been completed at a North Grant Street property, after staff and commissioners reviewed photos and the applicant—s description.

The applicant told the commission that porch deck boards, stair treads and one-sided handrail replacement had been completed because the boards were rotted and unsafe. The applicant said the porch skirting was added and that the contractor used treated lumber for structural elements. The applicant said the work was performed before she realized historic-district approval was required.

Commissioners and staff discussed whether the work matched historic appearance and whether the scope required a building permit. Staff advised that, because more than simple board replacement occurred, a building permit will be required for the deck boards, stair treads and railing work. One commissioner noted the risers were not replaced and the wrought-iron railing on one side remained unchanged.

The commission moved to approve a certificate of appropriateness, citing compliance with the U.S. Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation and section 64-11(c) of the city—s historic preservation regulations; the motion carried unanimously. Commissioners added that treated lumber used in the repairs should be painted once it has finished any required conditioning period and suggested adding trim across the top of any skirting to improve appearance.

Staff told the applicant to coordinate with the building official to obtain any required permits and to follow up on painting and finish details. The building official had indicated a permit would be required for deck boards, stair treads, risers and railing replacement after the fact, staff said.