Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves repairs and limited alterations to Fisher Place (EBY25003)
Summary
The Historic Preservation Commission unanimously approved repairs, siding replacement and foundation work for the Fisher Place (file EBY25003), finding the proposed work compatible with the Secretary of the Interior’s standards while accommodating necessary rehabilitation.
The Eby's Landing National Historical Reserve Historic Preservation Commission unanimously approved application EBY25003, authorizing elevation, foundation work, siding replacement and other repairs to the Fisher Place, a contributing resource in the reserve.
Staff presented the proposal and described the key elements: elevating the house in place to install a new foundation, replacing severely deteriorated siding with cement lap siding intended to resemble wood, removing one failing brick chimney and replacing the other with a synthetic brick element, repairing a roof area damaged by a fallen tree, and modestly altering window openings to accommodate a relocated kitchen and required counter heights.
Preservationist Josh Pitts summarized the historic significance and staff’s review. “The proposed modifications to the Fisher Place residence...have been carefully designed to ensure the preservation of the property's historic integrity while accommodating necessary rehabilitation efforts,” Pitts said, noting the structure meets National Register criteria A (recreation and tourism) and C (architectural characteristics). He told commissioners the north façade’s original window pattern influenced staff recommendations to retain the two left windows and the single right window on that elevation.
Applicant representative Larry Korsick and contractor Cody West described the practical reasons for material choices, emphasizing durability in a highly exposed site the applicant calls “her tiny island.” The applicant proposed fiberglass doors and asphalt composition shingles to reduce future maintenance needs.
Commissioners asked about reclaiming original materials such as chimney bricks. Pitts said much of the exterior fabric is severely deteriorated and that while reclaimed material would be preferable, the chimney and many exterior materials would effectively be replaced in-kind due to structural concerns and the need to lift the house for a new foundation.
Public comment was limited: staff recorded a single phone inquiry seeking clarification; no objections were filed in the public comment period. Commissioner Bronson moved to accept EBY25003 as presented; Commissioner Jay Adams seconded. The motion passed unanimously. Staff will finalize permit filings and monitor compliance with Secretary of the Interior rehabilitation standards.
