Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Local Government Appointments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council appoints Laura Raum to planning commission amid questions about election practice
Summary
The Charlestown Town Council voted unanimously to appoint Laura Raum as first alternate to the Planning Commission after public comment and debate over whether the council should respect the order of vote totals from a recent election.
The Charlestown Town Council unanimously appointed Laura Raum to the Planning Commission’s first alternate seat Monday night, following public comments and a contested discussion about whether the council should promote the next-highest vote-getter from the recent election.
The appointment filled a vacancy created when an elected alternate resigned. Councilor Sarah moved to appoint Laura Raum; the motion was seconded and passed in a 4–0 roll-call vote.
The debate centered on local practice and voter intent. Ruth Plattner, a long-serving planning commission member, urged the council to “follow what the voters did in the election and keep Carol as first option,” saying the council historically promoted elected alternates in order. Supporters of that practice argued moving an unelected candidate ahead of an elected one would undermine recent vote results.
Council supporters of appointing Raum said the Town Charter gives the council discretion to fill alternate seats and that the charter’s vacancy provisions were being followed. Councilors who backed Raum noted her experience: Raum told the council she had prior service as a planning-board secretary in Little Compton, work in building-and-zoning offices, and familiarity with meeting minutes and legal recordkeeping.
Carol Moussa, an incumbent planning commissioner who was elected as an alternate in November, said she had twice been elected by voters and had already performed as first alternate on several occasions. She asked the council to honor voters’ preference and move her up, but the council decided to appoint Raum to alternate No. 1 and leave Moussa in the alternate No. 2 seat she currently holds.
Council members emphasized the short-term, procedural nature of the appointment: the Town Charter requires the council to announce vacancies at least one month before appointment, accept applications, and then may appoint a replacement to serve until the next general election.
The council also noted the commission will have a full slate of alternates and members to continue work on zoning and housing projects now scheduled this winter.
The council did not vote on filling a second alternate seat at the meeting; the charter requires any further appointment to be advertised and considered at a future meeting.
