Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Comments topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Residents and students debate trans visibility and library materials at Auburn council public forum
Summary
Multiple speakers used the open forum to dispute coverage of a student 'Trans Day of Visibility' event and library materials. Some speakers condemned the event and library holdings; others defended student speech, cited Tinker v. Des Moines and urged inclusion and protection of students.
A vigorous exchange took place during citizens' communications at Auburn's April 1 meeting over a recent Trans Day of Visibility event at Auburn High School and the content of materials held by the Auburn Public Library.
Martha Shout told the council she was "urging parents" to contact school leaders and decried materials she called "inappropriate" in the library's collection. In contrast, Jeff Walker identified himself as the father of a senior who participates in the club and described what he called the students' "courage" in working with school administration: "They have worked with the administration and the teachers, the superintendent, and the school board to earn their right like every other club at Auburn High School," Walker said.
Several speakers defended the students' right to expression. Gabriel Dunham summarized Trans Day of Visibility as "an annual day ... dedicated to celebrating the accomplishments and victories of transgender and gender expansive people while raising awareness of the work that is still needed to combat discrimination and violence." Miranda Bachelor cited the 1969 U.S. Supreme Court decision Tinker v. Des Moines, noting that case protects students' speech rights in public schools.
Other residents urged compassion and inclusion. Sarah Collins thanked the library staff for serving "every member of the community, not just a religious view," and Deborah Beal described the consequences for a family member who delayed coming out because of fear of rejection.
Council members listened and at least one councilmember spoke from the dais to condemn misinformation and to state support for residents and students who "want to be who they want to be." The council did not take any formal action on school or library policy during the meeting; city officials reiterated that some matters (school policies and library collection decisions) fall under the authority of the Auburn City Schools or the library administration rather than the city council.
Speakers who addressed the council reflected sharply different views on public schools, library holdings and student speech. The council's public record shows the comments were delivered under "citizens open forum" and that attendees were asked to provide name and address for the record.
