Senate adopts resolution affirming diversity, equity and inclusion after sharp debate, 19-18

The Michigan Senate adopted Senate Resolution 18 by a vote of 19-18, affirming that the Senate "recognizes diversity, equity, and inclusion as essential foundational principles for achieving the American dream" and encouraging institutions across the state to adopt those principles.

Senator Stephanie Chang introduced the resolution and delivered an extended floor statement arguing DEI advances opportunity, economic prosperity, and inclusion. Chang said, "A key part of the American dream are the principles of diversity, equity, and inclusion," and described DEI policies as "about removing barriers to opportunity, strengthening productivity, increasing innovation, and building a healthy vibrant economy."

Opponents called the resolution inappropriate and politically divisive. Senator Runstead argued that "equity means an outcome. Demanding an outcome. Not equality, where everyone gets an equal chance, but making sure an outcome is achieved, which is against the fourteenth amendment equal protection clause." Minority Leader Senator Nesbitt provided a lengthy explanation of his no vote, saying in part, "The DEI agenda reeks of the same big government nonsense ... telling people who to hire, who to promote, how to think."

Senator Irwin spoke in favor of the resolution, saying efforts to "widen the circle" and "bring all Americans in" were consistent with shared American values.

The roll call on the adoption was recorded after the ayes and nays were ordered. The secretary announced 19 ayes and 18 nays; the majority of members elected and serving having voted in the affirmative, the resolution was adopted.

Background: The rules were suspended to allow immediate consideration of the resolution. The debate included requests to print remarks in the journal and several members used the floor to explain their votes.