Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Committee Votes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee advances several bills; roll calls and voice votes record mixed outcomes
Summary
The Senate Natural Resources Committee acted on multiple bills in a single session, approving several by voice or roll call and rejecting some amendments. Key measures advanced include House Bills 270, 285 and 291; vote tallies and amendment outcomes are summarized below.
The Senate Natural Resources Committee voted on multiple bills during the session, advancing House Bills 270, 285 and 291 and recording roll-call results or voice outcomes for amendments and the bills themselves.
The actions covered coordination amendments and final recommendations to the full Senate. Committee members used a mix of voice votes, proxy votes and roll-call votes during the session; several amendments failed and others were adopted before bills were moved forward.
Why it matters: The committee’s recommendations send bills to the floor with the panel’s endorsement or with recorded objections, shaping which measures the full Legislature considers and signaling points of contention for floor debate.
What the committee did
- House Bill 270: Committee adopted a coordination amendment described as “coordination language between all of the MEPA bills” and then moved a “do pass” recommendation on HB 270 as amended. The amendment was adopted by voice vote (proxies recorded). The record shows proxies cast aye votes by Senator Usher, Senator Marjell and others; the committee put the amendment on and moved the bill as amended.
- House Bill 285: The committee considered multiple amendments. One amendment (described in the transcript as killing Senate Bill 221 if HB 285 passed) failed on a roll call with 4 voting yes and 7 voting no. Later, a coordination amendment was moved and adopted; the committee then recommended “do pass” on HB 285 as once amended. Final roll-call on the bill (as amended) was 7 yes and 4 no; the committee chair said he would carry the bill on the floor.
- House Bill 291: After discussion that included objections on federal-state standards, the committee conducted a roll-call vote. The tally was 6 voting yes and 5 voting no; the chair said he would carry the bill on the floor.
Votes at a glance (committee actions)
- HB 270 — Amendment adopted (voice, proxies recorded); committee moved a do-pass on HB 270 as amended (voice vote; proxies recorded). Vote tally: voice vote (proxies recorded); individual roll-call tally not specified in transcript.
- HB 285 — Amendment (described as eliminating SB 221 if HB 285 passed) failed on roll call: 4 yes, 7 no. Later amendment(s) adopted; final committee recommendation: do pass as amended. Roll-call tally on final: 7 yes, 4 no.
- HB 291 — Final committee recommendation: do pass. Roll-call tally: 6 yes, 5 no.
Details and context
The committee used proxies for members not in the room and combined voice and roll-call votes depending on the item. Several amendments were framed as “coordination” language intended to align bills across related measures. Some members raised constitutional or policy objections during debate, notably to provisions that members said would change state authority vis-à-vis federal standards.
Ending
Committee recommendations now go to the full floor. The transcript shows who recorded proxies and some named roll-call votes; full roll-call detail and the bill text will be on the committee’s posted minutes and the legislative docket for anyone seeking the complete vote record.
