Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves storm-window and exterior repairs at 1710 Sixth Street; owner to retain original interior windows
Summary
The Bay City Historic District Commission approved a certificate of appropriateness for exterior storm windows and related repairs at 1710 Sixth Street, allowing replacement of exterior storms while preserving the property’s original interior windows; the owner asked about drip-edge repairs and received staff guidance for contractors and permits.
The Bay City Historic District Commission on March 12 approved a certificate of appropriateness for exterior storm windows and related exterior repairs at 1710 Sixth Street, where the owner said most interior windows remain original and contain historic wavy glass.
Linda Zura, the property owner, told commissioners she wants to keep the original interior windows where possible but needs replacement storm windows because existing aluminum storms have deteriorated and their clips no longer function. She described using Arnold Sauder storm windows (aluminum) and said installers typically “wrap” the window opening with a finished aluminum or similar trim so the installation looks clean.
Commissioners approved the work as described in the applicant packet. The motion recorded at the meeting states the applicant demonstrated compliance with the U.S. Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Rehabilitation (Standards 1–6, 9 and 10) and the city’s historic preservation regulations; commissioners voted in favor and the motion carried.
Why it matters: The owner emphasized preserving original interior windows and the historic glass while installing functional exterior storms that permit ventilation with screens. The commission’s approval allows the owner to proceed with permitted exterior work while retaining the interior historic fabric when feasible.
Key details from the discussion - Owner preference: Mrs. Zura said she wants to retain original interior windows with wavy glass and only replace exterior storm windows to make them operable and screened for summer use. - Storm system: Applicant proposed aluminum storm windows from Arnold Sauder; installation typically includes a finished trim around the exterior of the opening to integrate the storm into the façade. - Finish/color: Owner noted prior installers used a gray caulk that was visually prominent; commissioners and staff discussed the importance of matching visible caulk/trim color to the window/frame for a clean appearance. - Drip edge and trim: Owner raised concerns about a deteriorating drip edge on the house; commissioners suggested wood repair rather than vinyl wrapping to preserve historic appearance and offered to provide contractor referrals informally after the meeting (city does not formally endorse contractors). - Permits and follow-up: Staff advised the owner to contact building/planning staff and noted an approval was granted; one commissioner told the owner to contact a city staff member (Mr. Dyer) to obtain necessary permit information.
Action and next steps The certificate of appropriateness approval allows the owner to proceed to obtain building permits and schedule installation; staff advised follow-up with planning and building staff and advised that color/finish choices and installation details be consistent with the historic character as described in the application packet.
