Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Design Alteration topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Plan Commission approves third‑story addition at 600 Oregon Street; siding material accepted
Summary
The Plan Commission approved a design-alteration review permitting a small third‑story addition (a penthouse-like room) at 600 Oregon Street and determined that the proposed lap siding and associated materials are acceptable, voting 7‑0.
The City of Oshkosh Plan Commission approved a design alteration review to add a third-story penthouse-style room to a mixed commercial-residential building at 600 Oregon Street, and the commission approved the proposed materials and design as presented in the staff report (motion carried 7-0).
Staff described the property as a mixed commercial-residential development in the Central Mixed Use District and said the proposal adds a third-story room approximately 9 feet 1 inch high, accessed by an internal spiral staircase from a single second-floor unit. The applicant described the addition as a flexible amenity space (reading room, lounge or recreation area) and said the exterior would use horizontal lap siding in a brown tone to be contextual with the building’s brick facades and the previously approved adjacent garage building. Staff noted central mixed use district design standards require exterior materials to be compatible with nearby buildings and raised a specific question for the commission about whether lap siding is appropriate on an existing masonry building; staff recommended the commission make that determination.
Applicant representative Matt Villanola described material details: much of the new third-story appearance will be windows from the street and the trim above the windows will be broader, masonry-style trim boards rather than typical narrow lap siding. A public commenter, Chris North of 611 Oregon Street, spoke in support of the project. Commissioners asked technical questions about access (staff confirmed only the north unit will have access to the third-story room) and confirmed the project is not on the historic register. After discussion — including a suggestion that providing a physical material sample would have been helpful — the commission made an affirmative determination and approved the design and materials as shown in the staff report. The vote was recorded as 7-0.
The applicant said the previously approved garage will be completed as part of the overall project; staff will verify final construction plans and any required consistency with CMU district design standards during permitting.
