Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Historic Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Historic Preservation Commission approves removal of failing brick walls at Geneva Street properties
Summary
The Opelika Historic Preservation Commission approved staff'recommended removal of deteriorating brick retaining walls at properties on Geneva Street, citing structural failure and a planned driveway that requires regrading. Commissioners discussed whether portions of the upper wall could be preserved and noted photographs and past precedents.
The Opelika Historic Preservation Commission on March 2025 voted to approve removal of deteriorating brick retaining walls at properties on Geneva Street that were described in the meeting as "4 10 4 16 and 4 56 4 7 2 Geneva Street." Staff recommended the demolition after describing widespread cracking and failure and because a new driveway and regrading were planned.
Staff said the walls were falling in several areas and showed photographs of cracked sections and of the driveway approach. "Staff recommends approval of removing both ... walls that are in place," a staff member said during the presentation. The commission then moved and approved the recommendation without recorded roll-call votes.
The exchange included questions about grade and whether the upper wall could be salvaged. One commissioner asked, "How hard would it be for y'all to try to save the upper wall?" The staff responder said the finished grade behind the upper wall would be lower than the house and that the new grade and driveway necessitated changes. Another commissioner said the wall "is in terrible shape" and later added, "I just I don't see any value in saving it. It's it's a brick wall. It affects what's being built there ... I don't see the point in saving an old brick wall."
Commissioners discussed a local precedent in which a neighboring property replaced a removed wall with new brick work and noted the Catholic church wall had been rebuilt by the city. Staff also said photos in the packet and examples from other nearby projects informed the recommendation.
The commission approved the motion in line with staff recommendation; the meeting transcript records voice votes with commissioners saying "aye" and the chair stating the motion was approved. The record does not include a numbered roll-call tally. The permit file or subsequent building permit review will determine whether and how any replacement wall or landscaping is constructed.
