Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Alcohol Licensing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
City Attorney Explains Alcohol‑license Renewal, Nonrenewal Triggers and Hearing Process; Notices to Two Licensees Approved
Summary
City Attorney Cale Decker outlined the renewal calendar, statutory grounds for nonrenewal and the hearing process; two licenses were flagged for notices of intent to not renew and the Public Safety Committee approved issuing those notices.
City Attorney Cale Decker delivered a refresher to the Common Council on March 18 about the annual alcohol license renewal process, emphasizing statutory limits and the formal steps the city must follow when pursuing nonrenewal.
Decker explained that existing retail alcohol licenses represent a property interest and that the application deadline for renewal filings is April 15; licenses filed by that date obligate the council to act by June 15, while late applications are considered as soon as practicable. He said most renewals are routine and returned to the council en masse; only a small number are flagged for further investigation.
Two specific nonrenewal triggers were described: - Unpaid wholesaler indebtedness reported to the city clerk (a wholesaler can report an account that remained unpaid for a statutory period). If unresolved at renewal, staff will recommend notice of intent to not renew. - Lack of a valid seller’s permit. State law requires proof of a seller’s permit with the license application; if a seller’s permit has been revoked midyear and is not restored by renewal, the license cannot be reissued.
Decker emphasized that a council vote on “intent to not renew” is an initial procedural step under Section 125.12 of state law, not a final finding. If notice is issued, the licensee may demand a hearing; the Public Safety Committee serves as the hearing body, which hears evidence and is the finder of fact. Decker repeatedly counselled the council to keep an open mind and to consider only evidence presented at a formal hearing rather than public statements or social media.
Clerk and staff updates: the clerk reported that one previously flagged license (1 Stop West Allis Food and Liquor) satisfied a reported wholesaler debt earlier that afternoon and was removed from the list, leaving two licenses for staff action.
Action taken: the Public Safety Committee later approved issuing notices of intent to not renew to Yeager’s LLC (class B license, alleged wholesaler indebtedness) and Steffek LLC (class B license, alleged lack of a seller’s permit). If a hearing is demanded, it will be scheduled before the Public Safety Committee; if the matter is not cured by June 30, a nonrenewal would result in the license expiring on that date.
Why it matters: the city must follow state statutory procedures to avoid successful administrative appeals; nonrenewal is a technical, multistep process that gives licensees notice and an opportunity to contest allegations in a hearing.
Ending: Staff will issue notices as recommended; timing and next steps depend on whether licensees demand hearings or cure the underlying issues before renewal.
Speakers quoted: Cale Decker (City Attorney); City Clerk (staff update).
