Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Retiree Health And Insurance topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee hears fire-department requests on retiree coverage; staff warns of large costs
Summary
Personnel committee members reviewed several requests from the fire department, including earlier retiree health eligibility, opt-out bonuses, and alternative premium tiers. Staff outlined high estimated costs and recommended negotiations through labor contracts rather than unilateral benefit expansions.
The Franklin City Personnel Committee discussed requests from the fire department for changes to retiree health insurance and other health-plan elements, but staff cautioned the committee that most of the requests would carry substantial long-term costs.
Committee staff summarized the fire department’s key asks — lowering retiree-health eligibility from age 53 with 25 years of WRS service to age 50, instituting an opt-out bonus for employees who waive city coverage, offering a three-tier premium (single, couple, family) and evaluating a move from the city’s self-insured plan to an insured or state plan — and offered cost and operational context for each.
Staff estimated that allowing retirement three years earlier (from 53 to 50) for a firefighter with 25 years of service could add roughly $64,000 per retiree (the staff figure converted the department’s stated annual retiree-health cost of about $254,000 for a 12-year retiree period into the incremental cost for three additional years). Staff emphasized that adopting that change across multiple employees would multiply the cost materially.
On an opt-out bonus, staff noted roughly 54 employees already waive city coverage; providing buyouts or opt-out payments to increase opt-outs would require paying those already waiving employees or establishing a new ongoing expense. Staff estimated an opt-out program at roughly $3,000–$4,000 per person could exceed $200,000 annually if applied broadly.
Staff also described how the city’s self-insured structure limits annual premium swings because the city carries stop-loss insurance rather than paying full-market premium increases. Staff said the city’s stop-loss threshold has been increased over time and is currently near $100,000; stop-loss premium for a family was stated as about $310 per month, while the city’s PPO family premium was described as roughly $2,400 per month and the high-deductible family plan roughly $2,100 per month. Staff said moving to the state health plan could incur higher costs because the state’s plan applies experience-rating and could add a surcharge (staff cited an example where an experience surcharge could reach about 30% for a municipality with recent high-cost claims).
Staff recommended that many of the fire department’s requests are bargaining items for labor contract negotiations rather than unilateral administrative changes and said staff would provide the meeting recording and the committee’s written responses to the fire department representative who had presented requests at the previous meeting.
Ending: No changes to retiree-health eligibility or premium structure were adopted at the meeting; staff will provide the committee’s discussion notes and cost context to the fire-department representative for bargaining and follow-up.
