Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
County recommends Aetna (with CVS pharmacy) to replace Cigna for employee medical and pharmacy contracts
Summary
Boulder County staff told commissioners they unanimously recommend awarding the self‑funded medical administration contract to Aetna (with CVS integrated pharmacy) after an RFP process; staff estimated 4.7% overall savings and a 21% reduction in medical administration fees versus the incumbent.
Boulder County Human Resources on Aug. 12 recommended awarding two benefits contracts — medical administration and pharmacy benefits — to Aetna, with integrated pharmacy services through CVS, after a multi‑vendor RFP and evaluation process.
Panel review and finalists: Emily Cooper, Boulder County Human Resources, said the county’s self‑funded medical contract (currently with Cigna) entered its final year and that an RFP attracted proposals from six carriers for medical and seven for pharmacy. The evaluation panel — which included benefits‑advisory board members, HR staff and equity assessment tools — shortlisted finalists and considered pricing, provider networks, transition risk and employee impact.
Why Aetna: Cooper said Aetna’s proposal offered the broadest provider network for the county’s claims — estimating 97.6% of current claims would be in‑network under Aetna versus 94.1% under the incumbent — a three‑percentage‑point improvement. Aetna offered a three‑year rate guarantee for medical administration fees and a $225,000 annual claim credit. For pharmacy, CVS as an integrated vendor would avoid prescription transitions and allow a single ID card and consolidated prior‑authorization processes. The panel estimated 4.7% overall savings for medical and pharmacy combined and a 21% savings in per‑employee medical administration fees (estimated annual administration fees of $819,780). Cooper said the unanimous panel recommendation was to award the medical administration RFP to Aetna and pharmacy services to Aetna with CVS.
Transition and employee outreach: County staff acknowledged potential disruption concerns and said analysis used actual claims data to map provider availability. Cooper said the county plans robust employee communications and tools (including Aetna provider lookup and RightwayHealthcare navigation) to minimize transitions; Aetna uses CVS for pharmacy so the county anticipates no change to prescription vendors.
Union context and procurement: Cooper noted the county and the Boulder County Employees Union (CWA) were negotiating a first contract but that the county would continue benefits administration under its current authority to avoid interruptions.
Board action: Commissioners voted to accept the panel’s recommendation and award the RFPs as presented.
Sources: Human Resources presentation, RFP summary materials, and Aug. 12 Boulder County Board of County Commissioners meeting.
