City staff and partners on Aug. 11 presented a proposal to install art and banners near the Hopi Building in Heritage Square, and commissioners discussed options ranging from temporary rotating pieces to a permanent sculpture.
Shane Anderson, who said he has been meeting with downtown partners and representatives of the Hopi Scribe economic development group, described the goal as increasing activation and visual interest in the northern downtown area. Proposals discussed included short-term banners, temporary or rotating sculptures and a permanent piece sited in an existing planter near the amphitheater and stairwell.
Staff noted practical constraints: the planter area is visible but partially obscured by tall plantings; commissioners suggested lowering or replacing the plantings to increase visibility. Staff also warned that the amphitheater sits on a parking-garage slab with structural weight limits; any heavy sculpture would need structural review or use anchoring approaches that avoid intrusive bolting.
Commissioners debated whether the city should pursue a temporary loaned sculpture as part of the rotating multicultural sculpture exhibition (staff said loan fees can be up to $24,000 per year) or procure a permanent work. Staff gave a broad cost range for a permanent sculpture of $25,000 to $250,000 and said staff will provide more precise dollar amounts for the October retreat. Staff also referenced a previous scroll project that cost about $135,000 as a point of comparison.
Commissioners suggested holistic treatments that would tie railings, planters and lighting together, and to consider coordinating design calls so a single artist might produce multiple elements. Commissioner Ruan noted that temporary, changing installations can draw repeat visits and cited Geneva’s rotating flower clock as an example. Commissioner comments raised concerns about visibility, activation and pedestrian circulation in the square.
Staff will refine the scope, produce cost estimates and return potential procurement options and priority ranking at the October retreat for commission action.