Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Medicare Advantage Incentives topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Speaker warns Medicare Advantage incentives are misaligned, cites solvency risk
Summary
An unnamed speaker at a meeting said Medicare Advantage payment incentives are misaligned, warned the Medicare Part A trust fund could be exhausted in about seven years, and urged regulators, MedPAC and lawmakers to align incentives and review reporting practices.
Unnamed speaker, a speaker at the meeting, warned that payment incentives for Medicare Advantage plans are misaligned and urged regulators and lawmakers to act, saying the Medicare Part A trust fund could be exhausted in about seven years.
“I care passionately about this subject. I wanna put a couple things out. I'm actually a fan of managed care,” the speaker said, arguing that the way incentives are currently structured does not reward keeping people healthier.
The speaker cited what they described as recent analyses and oversight inquiries, including “med pack” reports, and said investigators have obtained tens of thousands of pages of plan distribution and scoring documents. They said those materials show cases in which individuals were risk-scored with diagnoses they do not have and urged further review of scoring and payment practices.
“If the med pack report is correct … you have 15 to 20 and, some reports that may be even slightly higher,” the speaker said, describing a disparity between Medicare Advantage payments and fee-for-service costs and noting that Medicare Advantage was expected to be paid near fee-for-service levels when it was expanded. The speaker added that, across the next decade, the government’s baseline obligation “looks like it's $16,000,000,000,000,” and called the issue one of the federal government’s largest fiscal challenges.
The speaker recommended collaborative work with insurers, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC) and members of both parties to realign incentives. They said some Medicare Advantage organizations have cooperated with oversight inquiries while others have been less forthcoming and that news investigations — including items from The Wall Street Journal and ProPublica, the speaker said — will be submitted for the record.
The remarks were discussion and advocacy; the transcript does not show any formal motion, vote or directive resulting from the comments. The speaker said they would return material from outside reporting to the committee at a later time and then yielded back to the chair.
Why this matters: The speaker framed the issue as a combination of fiscal risk (a projection for Part A trust fund solvency), program integrity (alleged incorrect risk scores), and policy design (how incentives are set for Medicare Advantage relative to fee-for-service). No formal committee action or staff assignment is recorded in the transcript provided.
