Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Promotion Policy 3537 topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
MMSD board adopts updated promotion policy after months of review; public raises literacy and retention concerns
Summary
The Madison Metropolitan School District board approved an updated promotion policy (3537) June 23 after discussion at the instruction work group. Public commenters urged stronger literacy-based promotion criteria and amendments to ensure retention is used when students lack grade-level reading and math skills.
The Madison Metropolitan School District Board of Education voted unanimously June 23 to approve revised Policy 3537, which governs promotion of students across grades, after review in the district’s instruction work group.
Supporters of the revision said it clarifies pathways for students with disabilities and aims to standardize practices across the district. Board member Nikki VanderMeelen told colleagues the update “for the first time, individuals with disabilities are specifically mentioned, are specifically included, and have an actual path to graduation besides just an assigned degree.”
During public comment, speakers urged changes to ensure that students are not promoted without the literacy skills necessary for later success. Gerald Sternberg and Marlee Sternberg urged the board to allow retention when students are multiple years behind grade-level benchmarks and to remove language that could permit promotion for students who have not completed personal reading plans.
Public commenters cited MMSD literacy statistics presented at the meeting: they said a low percentage of Black and Hispanic students and students with individualized education programs (IEPs) are meeting grade-level literacy benchmarks, and they argued promotion without literacy carries long-term costs. “Promoting students without literacy is a short term solution with long term costs,” one speaker said.
Board discussion acknowledged the public concerns; several board members said they supported the policy because it created explicit inclusion and pathways for students with disabilities and because the instruction work group had revisited the policy multiple times.
District staff said the board will continue refining implementation details through the Instruction Work Group and school teams. The adopted policy is effective immediately, per the board motion.
The board also noted the policy drew strong interest during public comment and said it will monitor implementation and report back through regular work-group meetings.
