Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Employee Benefits Stop Loss topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves stop‑loss contract with Cigna after commissioners raise procurement concerns
Summary
At a special called meeting, the Williamson County Board of Commissioners approved a contract with Cigna for stop‑loss insurance after several commissioners raised concerns that the stop‑loss portion of the RFP had been “buried” and that limited bidding reduced competition.
Williamson County commissioners on June 9 approved a resolution authorizing the county mayor to sign a contract with Cigna Healthcare for stop‑loss insurance that will cover the county’s self‑insured employee medical plan. The resolution (6 25 1) was presented at a special called meeting and passed on a recorded vote of 23‑0.
The purchase drew pointed questions from several commissioners about the procurement process. Commissioner Webb, who explained the county is self‑insured and that stop‑loss must be in place annually, said the purchasing and insurance committee followed “the rules of the state purchasing guidelines” and that the stop‑loss line had been discussed at committee meetings. Webb said bids were posted on the county website and through standard distribution channels and that the committee received only one bid specifically for stop‑loss coverage after selecting Cigna for primary medical coverage.
Commissioner Lisa Hayes and Commissioner Richards said the stop‑loss specification was not clear in the original RFP and was effectively buried within a larger medical/prescription RFP. Hayes said, “When you name an RFP for medical and prescription, stop‑loss … was hidden within that document. That’s putting us in a huge disadvantage. No wonder there’s only one person that bid.” Richards said the county’s rules require resolutions that spend money be referred to the budget committee; he said this resolution did not show a contract attached, did not state a price or funding source on the face of the resolution and noted potential litigation risk if bidders can show inadequate public notice under state law.
Other commissioners urged improvements to the county’s procurement and benefits review process. Commissioner Greg Lawrence called for an independent benefits consultant and said non‑incumbent carriers often need more time and clearer data to submit credible stop‑loss quotes. Commissioner Stresser and others supported hiring a broker or consultant to broaden the vendor pool for next year.
County staff and committee members said the stop‑loss item had been discussed in purchasing and insurance committee meetings for months, that bids for casualty and medical coverage had been solicited widely, and that the stop‑loss must be in place to protect the county’s self‑insured plan. The resolution approving the contract with Cigna (6 25 1) was moved by Commissioner Megan Guffey and seconded by Commissioner Steve Smith and passed 23‑0. The minutes record that the bid solicitation produced multiple bids for primary medical coverage but only one bid for stop‑loss.
Commissioners said they intend to review procurement procedures to increase transparency and to seek a benefits consultant/broker to help obtain more competitive bids in future cycles. The county will proceed with the Cigna stop‑loss contract as approved while several commissioners said they will press to change the process for next year.
The action comes ahead of budget votes later in the June meeting that lawmakers said will consider broader employee benefits and pay‑structure changes.
