The Historic Preservation Commission approved a certificate of historic appropriateness for a 528‑square‑foot elevated pool to be installed at 1653 Boston Grill Road in the Hamlin Beach Community Historic District after a contested discussion about cultural character and visibility.

Staff reported the pool would be located on the home’s rear deck, match the existing deck height, be one story in height, and “will not be visible from the street,” noting the nearest contributing resources (God’s Way Healing and Worship Center and Benjamin’s Sweet Shop) are more than a quarter mile away. The parcel is in Special Management S‑3 and the VE flood zone; staff recommended approval with the usual condition that major changes follow section 21‑5‑m of the historic preservation ordinance.

Commission discussion included concerns that elevated pools and elevated homes are uncommon and could affect the community’s historic character. Commissioner Michael German moved to deny on the basis that the pool would compromise district integrity; that motion failed. Other commissioners emphasized that pools are an allowed use and that the pool’s placement behind the house meant it would not be visible from contributing resources or the right of way.

With those findings, the commission later approved the application by majority vote (recorded as a passing motion after the earlier denial motion failed). No written comments in support or opposition were filed with staff prior to the hearing. The commission’s approval is subject to the condition that major alterations be processed under section 21‑5‑m; appeal rights to the circuit court apply for 30 calendar days.