Historic commission approves backyard plastic shed with perpetual screening condition

The Nantucket Historic District Commission on June 17 approved a plastic storage shed at 24 Arlington Street on the condition that the structure remain screened from public view "in perpetuity."

The commission said the shed is not visible from Arlington Street and that existing plantings and a stipulation to add screening make the installation acceptable in the historic district. The vote registered one opposed member.

Commissioners and the applicant discussed sight lines from a narrow private way behind the house known as Driscoll's Way and whether the shed would be visible until plantings mature. Bernice Stedder, speaking for the property at public review, said she had installed evergreens that should grow to about 14 feet and screen the shed. Commissioner Ray noted he had visited the site and was satisfied that the shed would not be seen from Arlington. Commissioner Angus supported approval contingent on the screening condition. Commissioner Abby said she "would not be in favor" of approving plastic shed material except for lack of visibility, but the screening caveat resolved her concern.

The commission motioned to approve the application "as submitted with the caveat that it must be screened in perpetuity." The motion carried with one recorded dissent by Commissioner Abby.

Applicants must comply with the screening condition; the commission did not order other changes to the application.

The case came during the meeting's new-business docket; members reviewed the site and the board's decision was announced at the hearing.