Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Rural Housing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves RV as permanent residence in Red Lake after neighbors cite fire and waste concerns; condition added for fire mitigation plan
Summary
A conditional use permit to allow an RV to serve as a permanent residence on a one‑acre Red Lake parcel drew multiple public objections focused on fire risk and wastewater handling; the commission approved the CUP with a new condition requiring coordination with the local fire authority on a fire mitigation plan.
The Planning and Zoning Commission approved a conditional use permit on May 28 allowing an RV to be used as a permanent residence on a one‑acre parcel at 5742 Wilshire Drive in Red Lake, but only after commissioners added a requirement that the owner coordinate a fire‑mitigation plan with the local fire district.
Staff presented CUP25013 and said the applicant, Julian Tuscona, sought to keep an RV on the parcel as a residence; wastewater would be managed by hauled service or a dump station until a permanent wastewater system is installed, power would be provided by an accessory structure or RV pedestal, and the RV would be skirted. Staff recommended approval with conditions.
Multiple neighbors spoke in opposition at the public hearing, citing dense juniper fuels, a recent example of trash and code violations in surrounding lots, concerns about the presence of generators and noise, and the lack of a nearby dump station. Several neighbors reported observing the RV placed in a different location than the submitted site plan and a new deck and skirting already installed.
Commissioners discussed setbacks, compliance and enforcement mechanics, noise limits for generators (staff noted a 50 dB limit at property lines included in conditions), and whether the RV location matched the site plan. Commissioner Nancy Best asked staff to ensure screening rules in zoning code Section 3.17(b) are applied. To address neighbors’ safety concerns the commission added a condition requiring the applicant to coordinate with the local fire district and submit a fire mitigation plan (for example a Firewise assessment) to staff for verification during building/permit inspections.
Motion and vote: Vice Chair Wilson moved approval with the amended conditions; the motion passed (one commissioner recorded a dissenting vote). The permit will expire under standard time limits and is subject to code enforcement if conditions are not met.
Why it matters: the case highlights how the county manages nonstandard housing solutions in rural areas and demonstrates the commission’s use of conditions to address community safety concerns while allowing alternative housing forms.
