Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Mental Health Stigma topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Cohoes High survey finds students more likely to associate schizophrenia with violent crime than anxiety or no diagnosis
Summary
A Cohoes High School student survey of 90 classmates showed participants rated vignette subjects described as having schizophrenia as more likely to commit violent crimes than identical subjects described with generalized anxiety or no mental health disorder; property‑crime ratings did not vary significantly by diagnosis.
Nadia Osami, a senior at Cohoes High School, presented survey research on student perceptions linking mental illness to criminal behavior and found that classmates rated a vignette subject with schizophrenia as more likely to commit violent crime than identically described subjects with generalized anxiety disorder or no mental health disorder.
Osami surveyed 90 opt‑out consenting students in grades 9–12 using classroom distribution of paper questionnaires. Each respondent received three vignettes describing a hypothetical college student with one of three conditions—seasonal asthma (control/no mental disorder), generalized anxiety disorder and schizophrenia—and then rated the likelihood the subject would commit violent and property crimes.
Osami summarized the central result: participants were more likely to rate subjects labeled with schizophrenia as higher risk for violent crime, while ratings for property crime were similar across diagnosis conditions. She said the study “demonstrates that adolescents frequently associate schizophrenia with violence,” a finding she linked to media‑driven stigmas.
She acknowledged limitations including a small sample size (90 students), a narrow demographic drawn from a single high school and potential response bias tied to prior conditioning and stereotypes. Osami recommended larger, more diverse samples and interventions to reduce stigma in school settings.
Osami framed the work as part of an effort to “debunk these misconceived perceptions” and to spur collaborative efforts to increase treatment opportunities and more accurate public messaging about mental illness. She cited mentorship from David Ferri at NYU in developing the study protocol and said the survey used a two‑item follow‑up (likelihood of violent act; likelihood of property crime) after each vignette.
The presentation emphasized the need for early education programs to address stigma and the potential criminal justice consequences of misperceptions currently held by adolescents.
