Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Governance Transparency topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Trustees vote to keep water rate advisory group meetings closed; staff to post packets and summaries online
Summary
After extensive debate about transparency, trustee concerns about participant intimidation and a recorded roll call, the Town of Wellington Board of Trustees voted to keep the rate advisory group meetings closed to the public. Staff said advisory-group packets and summary notes will be posted online and that meetings have seven appointed members.
Town staff asked the Board of Trustees for direction on whether the town's Rate Advisory Group meetings should be open to the public or continue as closed sessions; after discussion, the board voted to keep the meetings closed.
Town Administrator Patty Garcia introduced the item and described the group's history. "This is the iteration of what we initially called a roundtable," she said, noting the town held closed roundtables in 2021 and 2022 and that the current advisory group has seven members appointed by trustees. Garcia said the group held an anonymous internal survey in which a majority said they supported openings with caveats; one member indicated they might not participate if meetings were public.
Why it matters: the group is a staffed, consultant-assisted forum to analyze complex utility-rate models and to prepare recommendations for the board. Trustees and staff described competing values: public transparency versus maintaining an intimate environment to encourage candid discussion and retain volunteers with technical knowledge.
Key discussion points
- Roles and format: Garcia said staff intends to post packets and summary notes on a website section for the advisory group; past sessions were closed and materials were not posted online in packet form. Staff said summary notes historically have not included individual participant names.
- Member impacts: trustees reported some appointed members told them they would not participate if sessions were public. Trustee Martin said one member told her they would not take part if meetings were public; another trustee noted the committee includes experienced volunteers who provide historic institutional knowledge.
- Transparency vs. protection: Trustee Cannon and others argued that opening the meetings could invite online harassment and misrepresentation of technical discussions; supporters of opening said residents should have the option to observe and that the town should favor greater access, though several proposed not live-streaming or recording sessions.
Board action and vote
Trustee (motion recorded in transcript) moved to continue keeping the Rate Advisory Group meetings closed. The roll call recorded in the transcript was: Trustee Cannon — Yes; Trustee Daley — Yes; Trustee Meyer — Yes; Trustee Teets — No; Trustee Wiegand — No; Trustee Mason — No; Mayor Ashoski — Yes. The motion carried and the meetings will remain closed. Staff said packets and summary notes will be posted online; staff also noted a town hall on July 15 will cover water rates and other topics.
Ending: Trustees emphasized that any recommendations produced by the advisory group will come before the full board in public session before any policy decision is made.
