Two students recorded in a provided transcript praised “Miss Ale” as “very deserving” of an award, saying she welcomed them on their first day, greeted people with a smile and helped them when needed.

The remarks, attributed to Student (Speaker A) and Student (Speaker B) in the transcript, emphasized her “positive attitude,” “generosity” and that she “always goes the extra mile to help Sam.” The transcript does not specify the type of award, the event at which the comments were made, or any formal action by EL PASO ISD related to the remarks.

Student (Speaker A) said, “Miss Ale is very deserving of this award because since the first day that I came on board, she was very welcoming, and she's always greeting people with a smile on her face, with a positive attitude.”

Student (Speaker B) added, “She's really sweet to us. Like, she always tries, like, her best to make us happy,” and later said, “Whenever we need her help, she's always there to help us.” The same speaker also said, “She's always going the extra mile to help Sam.”

The transcript identifies two speakers only by speaker labels; no student names, school, date or formal award action are provided. No motions, votes or other official district actions regarding an award are recorded in the supplied transcript excerpt.