Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Tree Management topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Orinda amends tree‑management code, keeping soil‑erosion review; council adopts ordinance 25‑03
Summary
The council adopted ordinance 25‑03 to amend Chapter 17.21 (tree management) of the Orinda Municipal Code, clarifying permit categories and reiterating that soil erosion and slope stability are findings in tree removal permits.
The Orinda City Council unanimously adopted ordinance 25‑03, amending Chapter 17.21 of the Orinda Municipal Code to adjust tree‑management permit categories and clarify criteria used when reviewing tree removal applications.
Why it matters: The amendment responds to homeowner concerns about insurance requirements and wildfire risk while keeping responsibilities for erosion and slope stability under city review. Council members and a public commenter stressed the need to balance wildfire risk reduction with protecting important trees and preventing hillside erosion.
City staff explained that the ordinance change creates more user‑friendly permit rules for certain vegetation removals and responds to homeowners who said insurers asked them to remove trees to remain insurable. Darren (planning staff) told the council that soil erosion and hillside impacts are already an explicit finding required for permit approval. “Soil erosion is something that is considered within our findings. That's actually not changing. That is a standard that we have used and we apply to any tree removal permits in the past, and we are maintaining that with this proposal,” Darren said.
A member of the public said she was concerned that the ordinance did not make the erosion discussion prominent enough and urged clearer wording on landslide risk and slope stability. City staff said the relevant finding appears in the permit category language and that the city will continue to apply soil‑erosion and related findings when reviewing permanent tree removal permits.
The ordinance, introduced as item F6, was adopted by unanimous vote after the council waived the full reading. Council members said they supported the limited, near‑term amendments but noted a larger review of protected species (for example, whether redwoods should be added to protected‑tree lists) may be appropriate later and could depend on the Moraga‑Orinda Fire District’s guidance.
What’s next: Staff will continue to process tree permits under the revised ordinance language and return with any future code changes if the council requests a more comprehensive tree‑management update.
