Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Alcohol Licensing topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Oshkosh council amends alcohol licensing rules after federal due-process concern
Summary
The Common Council approved an amendment to the municipal code governing alcohol licenses to remove conditional permits and add a post-issuance remedy process, following a federal court ruling. Councilors said the change preserves business openings while protecting public safety.
The Oshkosh Common Council on April 22 approved an amendment to the city municipal code that changes how the city issues alcohol licenses after a federal judge found problems with the prior conditional-permit process.
Councilors said the updated ordinance allows the city to issue full licenses when applicants provide reasonable assurances, while preserving the council’s ability to revoke or not renew a license if conditions are not later met. Council member Nichols, who moved the key amendment, said, “there has been a change in Wisconsin law that doesn't allow us to issue conditional permits.”
The amendment adds language to section 4-5a to require that for premises with items identified under section 4-4, the license will not be granted until conditions are corrected and verified by reinspection or until the applicant provides reasonable assurances to the council’s satisfaction. Nichols said the approach allows a business to open while giving the city “the ability to pull [a license] back if certain conditions are not met later.” Council member Larson, who supported the amendment, thanked staff for their work at a prior workshop and said the change “accomplishes all the same goals.”
City staff and the city attorney framed the change as a response to a district-court ruling in the Eastern District of Wisconsin that, according to council discussion, raised due-process questions about issuing conditional licenses. The council voted unanimously to adopt the amended ordinance. The city clerk’s roll call recorded seven yes votes.
The ordinance’s sponsors said the new procedure is intended to balance two aims: allowing new businesses to begin operations in a timely way and keeping formal mechanisms for inspectors and the council to address safety or code deficiencies discovered after initial licensing. Council discussion made clear the ordinance will take effect on passage and publication; one councilor noted that an applicant could still be required to complete outstanding inspections before being notified their license was available.
The council’s vote followed an amendment motion by Nichols and a second; the motion to amend passed 7-0 and the main ordinance as amended also passed on final action. The council discussed applying the revised procedure to two pending liquor-license requests and ultimately laid those items over so the amended ordinance could be published and applied consistently.
Councilors and staff said the change was prompted by legal advice and workshop discussion and is intended to standardize the approval process going forward.
