Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Insurance Agent Of Record topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Boone County commissioners table decision on agent-of-record letter after debate on bidding and service continuity
Summary
The Boone County Board of Commissioners paused action on an agent-of-record letter that would allow a single broker to solicit property/casualty quotes ahead of a June renewal, after extended discussion about competition, timing and ongoing service by the incumbent broker.
Boone County commissioners on April 21 tabled consideration of an agent-of-record letter for property and casualty insurance after a lengthy discussion about whether issuing the letter now would limit competition and risk service disruption ahead of the county’s June 30 renewal.
The vote to table followed competing arguments on whether to give “a fresh set of eyes” to the county’s insurance program or to preserve continuity with the incumbent broker while allowing time for a full request-for-proposals. Kyle Childs, who identified himself as an agent with Walter Hughes Insurance, told the commissioners his firm has worked with the county for years and encouraged them to let the existing arrangement run for one more year so an inspection and market process could be completed without service gaps. “We would like to honor, I guess, our commitments as well,” Childs said.
Commissioners who pushed to issue an agent-of-record letter said it was the only practical route to let another broker actively solicit competitive quotes from carriers that may not currently be engaged. Opponents said issuing the letter now would, depending on carrier practices, effectively give exclusive bidding access to a single broker and leave insufficient time—about 60 days before the county’s renewal—to complete thorough inspections and solicit competitive offers.
Several commissioners and the insurance broker described how municipal insurance markets have narrowed in recent years for certain exposures such as law-enforcement and jail liability. Childs said carriers that previously wrote county business (he cited Tokyo Marine as an example of a carrier that exited the municipal market) have left, making some carriers harder to replace.
After discussion, a commissioner moved to table the item until the next meeting; that motion carried. The record shows the decision was tabled for further review and for staff to gather more information about timing, the county’s existing contract arrangements, and options for a competitive process that avoids service interruptions.
