Commission approves extensive remodel at 443 East College with conditions to preserve front features

The Murphish Borough Historic Zoning Commission on April 15 approved a multi-item remodel plan for 443 East College Street, a 2,975-square-foot, one-and-a-half-story vernacular Craftsman fourplex that staff previously identified as a contributing structure in the historic district (construction date cited in the application as approximately 1925, with some earlier sources listing 1910).

Amelia, planning staff, summarized the applicant’s proposal and the staff concerns: applicant Brad Chambers proposed extensive exterior work including full siding replacement, window and door changes, removal of a metal exterior stair, replacement of porch columns and porch floor, brick skirting around the porch, replacement of chimneys, reroofing with architectural shingles and standing-seam metal on the porch, and a possible enlargement of a rear shed dormer. Staff told commissioners some requested changes did not meet the historic guidelines and that the commission would consider grouped votes on distinct elements.

Discussion focused on retaining character-defining features at the primary façade and porch. Commissioners emphasized keeping the front-facing window material and scale, the spacing and profile of the porch columns, the wraparound porch footprint and the stained-glass element. Commissioners voiced concern that incremental changes (wider siding reveals, vinyl windows, unfluted columns) could cumulatively make the house ineligible as a contributing structure.

The commission adopted a multi-part motion that approved the remodel…