Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Urban Forestry topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission selects big leaf maple as Library Park replacement tree after extended discussion
Summary
Following public input and a lengthy staff‑led discussion of native and ornamental species, the Recreation and Parks Commission voted 3‑2 to replace a removed mature Canary Island pine in Library Park with a big leaf maple.
The Recreation and Parks Commission voted 3‑2 to plant a big leaf maple at Library Park as the replacement for a mature Canary Island pine that died and was removed in March.
Christopher Henson, the city’s park superintendent and an arborist, reviewed options and said staff originally recommended a Norfolk Island pine because of its evergreen, vertical form and historical use as a “Christmas tree” feature in the park. Henson told the commission the women’s club that originally donated the Canary Island pine had asked for another Canary Island pine; Henson said he had received that input and other recent emails proposing a coast live oak.
“The goal is to find a replacement tree for Library Park. … a mature Canary Island pine donated by the El Segundo Women's Club located at Library Park died and was removed in March of this year,” Henson said.
Commissioners considered four primary options staff presented: Norfolk Island pine, Brisbane box, California sycamore, and coast live oak; several commissioners and public speakers also suggested additional natives such as big leaf maple and valley oak. Commissioners discussed irrigation impacts, root conflicts with the previous stump and grind, leaf litter and maintenance, shade needs, and whether the tree should be an evergreen “Christmas tree” form.
After debate and public remarks—including local residents and commissioners noting native plant benefits—the commission members voted. Commissioner Julie moved for the big leaf maple and the motion passed by a 3‑2 vote.
Clarifying details recorded during the discussion included: the removed Canary Island pine had been on site for about 70 years; staff said the prior tree’s root zone required grinding and that a new planting location or irrigation modifications might be needed depending on the selected species; cost ranges discussed for tree sizes included approximately $450–$600 for a 36‑inch box and about $1,500+ for a 48‑inch box requiring a crane for installation.
Next steps: staff will arrange procurement and planting logistics for the selected species, including any irrigation or site modifications recommended by the arborists.
