Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Public Works topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Council hears sidewalk inspection update after Iowa Supreme Court ruling; staff recommends continuing current program
Summary
Staff briefed the council on changes in sidewalk-liability law after a state court ruling. The city will continue its four-year inspection program and letter-notification process while monitoring legislative changes and pursuing regular program improvements.
Urbandale staff briefed the council April 15 on the city's sidewalk inspection program and a recent Iowa Supreme Court decision that limits municipal ability to shift liability to adjacent property owners via ordinance.
Kristen Brostrom, who presented the program update, said the city inspects sidewalks on a four-year rotation (typically in May with seasonal interns) and usually identifies between 50 and 250 defects per year. Defects the city targets include vertical lips (the city's working tolerance is 1 inch for tripping hazards) and substantial cracking or spalling that creates holes.
Brostrom said the current process notifies property owners of defects, offers an opportunity to complete repairs privately, reinspects in the fall and, if needed, bids a city repair program and invoices property owners for their share of the work. Historically, the city has relied on municipal code language that placed corrective responsibility on the adjacent owner; a recent Iowa Supreme Court ruling now limits the ability to transfer liability in that fashion.
City attorney and risk-management staff explained that the court decision removes an automatic transfer-of-liability defense that some insurers relied on; it does not prevent the city from continuing a sidewalk maintenance program. The city's insurer (ICAP) previously handled defense costs and occasionally denied claims as a transfer under the former code provisions; staff said the legal landscape is now different and ICAP's response may change.
After questions from council, staff recommended continuing the existing inspection and notification program and maintaining the one-inch vertical-lip tolerance. Council members discussed the tradeoffs of tightening the tolerance (for example, moving to a half-inch standard used in some neighboring jurisdictions) and staff said shrinking the tolerance would materially increase the number of identified defects and the volume of work residents would be asked to address.
Brostrom said the city continues to accept SeeClickFix requests and will incorporate them into inspections; staff also intends to refine intern training, photographic documentation and the workflow that moves identified repairs into bidding and invoicing.
Next steps
Council asked staff to continue the program as implemented, monitor claims under the new legal standard, and report back if the Legislature amends state code to reassign sidewalk liability. Staff noted a similar bill was discussed in the state House this session but did not pass the funnel; staff will monitor future sessions and return with policy options if needed.
