Commission recommends approval for 300 East Mountain infill but flags material authenticity

The Fort Collins Historic Preservation Commission on Feb. 19 voted 7-1 to recommend approval to the decision maker of a proposed two-story, mixed commercial-office building at 300 East Mountain Avenue, while explicitly finding the project does not meet the land-use-code requirement for authentic, durable primary materials.

Staff framed the commission’s role as advisory under the land use code’s cultural-resource protections and compatibility rules for new construction within 200 feet of a landmark. "Your role tonight will be to provide a formal recommendation via motion, to the decision maker," said Jim Bertolini, senior historic preservation planner. He explained that the abutting Armory building at 314 East Mountain is a city landmark and the only historic resource within the 200-foot buffer.

The proposal calls for a roughly 31-foot, two-story building with commercial space at street level and support or tenant space above. Portions of the project are programmed to functionally support the Armory, including a ticket window, bar extension and green room. Applicant…