Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Board Meeting Votes topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Utah State Board votes: rule changes, teacher-prep updates and funding directives
Summary
The Utah State Board of Education met March 26 and approved several administrative rules and documents, directed a discretionary‑funds audit of federal program costs, confirmed a deputy superintendent, and asked the governor to consider vetoes on two bills it judged potentially harmful to rulemaking and school funding.
SALT LAKE CITY — The Utah State Board of Education (USBE) took a series of final votes at its March 26 meeting on administrative rules, teacher-preparation materials, and a set of board-directed funding actions. The board also approved personnel confirmations and a number of disciplinary recommendations from its hearing panels.
The meeting combined several committee reports, a legislative update and public comment, and ended with multiple formal votes. Highlights:
- Rules and incorporated documents: The board approved R277-304 (teacher preparation programs) as amended and adopted an incorporated-by-reference document titled Special Education Preparation: Foundational Competencies (R277-304 incorporated document, draft 1) after a package of targeted wording changes to standard 6 (behavioral supports). The vote to adopt the Teacher Preparation Programs rule (draft 2) as amended passed on second and final reading. The board also approved R277-407 changing the LEA fee schedule due date (see article: LEA fee schedule deadline moved) and confirmed continuation of R277-417 (prohibiting LEAs and third-party providers from offering incentives or disbursements for enrollment) on second and final reading. The board approved R277-714 (unsafe school choice option) on second and final reading.
- Teacher-prep/special education: The board amended language used in the special-education competencies to replace some terms and to add clarifying items about data, functional behavior assessment practice, and disproportionate representation. The updated incorporated-by-reference document and the teacher-prep rule were approved on second and final reading.
- Discretionary funds / audit RFP: The board directed staff, if allowable state funds became available but no later than 65 days from the vote, to use up to $150,000 from the board’s discretionary/contingency funds to issue an RFP to retain outside auditors to (1) determine the federal funding USBE received over the past three years, (2) estimate the state and agency costs of administering those funds (including indirect and compliance costs), and (3) separate one‑time COVID/ESSER funds from ongoing federal funding in the analysis. The board added a clarifying amendment that the audit should line-item COVID‑19 relief funds separately. The motion passed after several amendments.
- Personnel and confirmations: The board confirmed Leah Voorhees as Deputy Superintendent for Student Achievement. The board also acted on multiple administrative and disciplinary recommendations from its licensing and appeals committees.
- Legislative & veto actions: Board staff briefed members on pending bills and where agency requests landed in the final appropriations cycle. The board voted to ask the governor to consider a veto on SB 37 (minimum basic tax rate amendments) and on SB 268 (rules review and oversight committee provisions as they pertained to USBE) — those votes were taken late in the session and reflect the board’s concerns about potential impacts on rulemaking and local school funding authority.
Why it matters: The meeting finalized technical updates to how the board expects future teacher-preparation programs to train special-education teachers, adjusted operational deadlines for LEA fee schedules to give districts more time in the wake of the legislative session, and authorized an external audit to better understand federal funding and the cost of compliance. Together, the votes change both administrative timelines and the evidence the board expects when it evaluates teacher preparation and federal program administration.
Detail and background: Many of the measures approved at the meeting were second-and-final-reading items that had been reviewed in committee. Where board members requested additional clarity, staff and committee leaders presented narrowly targeted wording changes before the final votes. The discretionary-funds audit motion passed after debate and two amendments: one removing the 60‑day automatic trigger, then substituting a 65‑day timeline and an authorization to use contingency funds if other allowable state funds were not available.
Next steps: Staff will carry out the board’s instructions: file rule updates for the approved rules and incorporated documents, post the revised LEA fee-schedule deadline, proceed with procurement steps to issue an RFP for auditors if funding is available (or use contingency funding if necessary), and prepare the formal letters requested by the board for the governor’s consideration of specified vetoes. Several items will return to the board or to committees for implementation and monitoring.
Votes at a glance (selected final votes from the meeting): - R277-417 (prohibiting LEAs/third-party providers incentive/disbursements): continued and approved on second & final reading — unanimous (recorded in committee earlier, final vote at board). - R277-714 (Unsafe School Choice Option): continued and approved on second & final reading — unanimous. - R277-304 (Teacher preparation programs / incorporated competencies): Adopted as amended (special education competencies incorporated-document and teacher-prep rule both approved on second & final reading); votes recorded in meeting. - R277-407 (LEA fee schedule deadline): board amended the rule to move the fee-schedule deadline from April 1 to July 1 (one-time adjustment), passed on first/final reading at meeting. - Discretionary funds audit RFP: Motion to use up to $150,000 from discretionary/contingency funds to issue RFP for external audit of federal funds (three-year lookback) and to separate COVID funds; passed after amendments (65‑day timing; ability to use contingency if needed). - Personnel: Confirmation — Leah Voorhees confirmed as Deputy Superintendent, Student Achievement.
Speakers and attributions in meeting minutes include board members voting at roll call, committee chairs presenting items, deputy superintendents and division directors (finance, policy, special education) presenting staff reports, and multiple public commenters earlier in the meeting (teacher awardees, PTA and union representatives, and others).
What we did not do: This summary omits the long technical roll-call transcript and staff-level line-item budget tables. It focuses on outcomes and next steps for the board and the agency.
Ending: Staff will prepare implementation steps and follow-up materials for the board (procurement materials, revised rule text filings, letters to the governor), and several items will be tracked by committees in coming weeks.
