Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Health Insurance Appeals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Department: independent external reviews overturned just over half of denials; market conduct team to probe trends
Summary
At a budget hearing, the Pennsylvania Insurance Department told lawmakers that independent external reviews overturned 50.6% of appealed adverse coverage decisions in the program's first year, prompting market conduct reviews and the possibility of restitution or penalties for insurers that show patterns of inappropriate denials.
The Pennsylvania Insurance Department reported that, in the first year after shifting external review oversight to the state, independent review organizations overturned just over half of adverse insurer decisions that reached external review. Commissioner Humphreys told legislators the department's data shows a 50.6% overturn rate for cases sent to independent review.
Representative Frio described cases where families and children were denied coverage for treatments later found to be medically necessary, including an anecdote about a 5‑year‑old with a life‑threatening condition whose coverage was initially denied and later overturned on appeal. "He's denied. How is that morally right?" Frio asked during the hearing, stressing the human stakes behind the statistics.
Humphreys said the department's market conduct unit will use the earlier reporting to drill down into company practices. "If we see a pattern or practice where a company continues to deny something that they should otherwise cover, that can subject them to restitution, fines, penalties," she said, identifying market conduct investigations and remediation as follow‑up work.
The department explained that external review generally comes after two levels of internal insurer review and that the independent review stage is designed to give an unbiased assessment of medical necessity and policy coverage. Humphreys said concern is not only that denials are overturned when appealed, but that many policyholders never pursue appeal rights and therefore never get the reversal their cases might merit.
The market conduct team — which the commissioner indicated would pursue examinations and potential enforcement — includes staff members specifically assigned to systematically review overturn trends, prior authorization practices, and whether insurers are meeting policy terms approved by the department.
