Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the School Start Times topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Senate panel strips statewide school-start mandate, returns schedule decisions to local boards
Summary
The committee adopted a strike-all amendment to Senate Bill 296 that removes a 2023 statewide requirement setting minimum start times for middle and high schools, sending local school boards responsibility to review and set start times after community discussion; the bill was reported favorably by roll call.
Senator Amy Bradley, sponsor of Senate Bill 296, told the Senate Education Committee that a 2023 law requiring middle schools not to start before 8:00 a.m. and high schools not before 8:30 a.m. created significant logistical and financial burdens for many districts and charter systems. The committee adopted a strike-all amendment that removes the statewide mandate and requires local school boards to “inform the community of the health, safety and academic impacts of sleep deprivation and consider the benefits of later school start times when adopting their transportation schedules.”
The amendment’s sponsor, Senator Bradley, said the 2023 law included a three-year implementation period that districts were to begin by July 1, 2026, but that districts’ analyses showed the mandate would force some to purchase additional buses, attempt to hire scarce bus drivers and shift dismissal times in ways that could harm students participating in extracurriculars, sports or employment. Bradley said some districts estimated needing as many as 19 additional buses and raised safety concerns about younger children waiting at bus stops before dawn.
Supporters and opponents submitted appearance forms but few took the podium; several district and education groups waived speaking time in support, including representatives identified in committee records from the Florida Association of District School Superintendents, Orange County Public Schools, Seminole County Public Schools and the Florida Education Association. Committee discussion acknowledged the scientific rationale for later start times while emphasizing varied local transportation, geographic and family circumstances.
Senator Berman said she supported later starts in principle but recounted that Palm Beach County school officials told her the statewide mandate was not feasible for a very large district. Senator Osgood and Senator Burgess likewise noted difficulties with bus routes, staffing and community rhythms and expressed support for returning the scheduling decision to local districts.
The committee first adopted Senator Bradley’s strike-all amendment by voice vote and then reported Senate Bill 296 favorably by roll call. Recorded on the roll call were: Senator Berman — yes; Senator Burgess — yes; Senator Collins — yes; Senator Davis — no; Senator Osgood — yes; Senator Yarbrough — yes; Senator Simon — yes. The clerk announced the measure “reported favorably.”
The bill, as amended, leaves start-time policy to district school boards, with a statutory requirement that districts discuss health, safety and academic impacts of sleep deprivation and consider later starts when setting transportation schedules. The amended bill does not set new statewide start times or require specific implementation steps, and it retains the committee’s summary that districts must engage their communities in decisions about schedules.
Votes at a glance SB 296 — Sponsor: Senator Amy Bradley — Action: Strike-all amendment adopted; bill reported favorably by roll call (Berman yes; Burgess yes; Collins yes; Davis no; Osgood yes; Yarbrough yes; Simon yes).
