Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Rose Cottage Preservation topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Committee presses Miami‑Dade Schools for time and access as Rose Cottage demolition remains on hold
Summary
Committee members urged Miami‑Dade County Public Schools to allow city preservationists access to document the Rose Cottage facade and explore alternatives to demolition; the school district said demolition was under consideration because of safety concerns but staff agreed to continue talks and seek limited additional time.
Miami Beach commissioners and preservation advocates pressed Miami‑Dade County Public Schools officials on Feb. 20 for more time and site access as they try to find a path to preserve the Rose Cottage, a contributing resource in the Española Way historic district.
The committee heard from Natalie Simon (Design and Planning Officer, Miami‑Dade County Public Schools), who said the district had placed demolition on hold at staff and that a professional assessment found the cottage “really not salvageable” and expressed concerns that the structure could become a liability by hurricane season. Simon said the district contracted a professional who concluded the building was in poor condition and that the district’s current plan would be demolition and sodding unless a viable preservation alternative is negotiated.
Preservation advocates, including Miriam Singer’s representative and the Miami Design Preservation League, told the committee they have a potential developer and a plan to reconstruct the facade as part of a larger, contiguous redevelopment that would bundle adjacent parcels, provide parking and include community uses. Michael Larkin, counsel for the preservation group, suggested a subdivision/lot split so the school district could convey the parcel to the city (or another party) and then record covenants to protect the resource — an approach he said could resolve liability concerns that the district has cited.
Committee members asked the district for limited additional time and for permission to access the site’s exterior areas to photograph and measure the cottage so preservationists can prepare reconstruction documentation. The district said a limited hold was already in place and agreed to continue discussions and follow up with the committee; commissioners asked staff to list the item on the next month’s agenda in case more time is needed.
Why it matters
Rose Cottage is part of the Española Way historic district; preservationists argued that detailed documentation and a narrow agreement could allow reconstruction of the facade as part of a broader development that includes benefits for the school and community while protecting public safety.
Next steps
The committee requested the district provide clear direction on access for documentation and to continue dialogue; committee members asked staff to place the item on next month’s agenda as a continuation.
