Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Land Use Policy topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Planning commission adopts amendments to short-term rental ordinance to clarify road, lot-size and proximity rules
Summary
The commission approved changes to the county short-term rental ordinance to use a functional-equivalent test for category 3 roads, allow STRs on smaller AG parcels administratively, and change neighborhood-concentration measurement from the '10 nearest dwellings as the crow flies' to a 300-foot radius.
The Humboldt County Planning Commission voted 5–0 to adopt three staff-proposed amendments to the short-term rental ordinance intended to fix implementation problems that emerged after the ordinance took effect.
Director Ford and planning staff told the commission the three targeted changes respond to “unintended consequences” encountered during administration. First, staff proposed replacing the ordinance’s strict engineering requirement that access roads be ‘‘built to a category 3 standard’’ with a functional-equivalent test so staff and applicants evaluate roads by operational safety and capacity rather than pavement construction details.
Second, staff proposed an exemption to allow short-term rentals on smaller parcels in agricultural (AG) zones to be processed administratively when lots are under a specified size (staff proposed parcels under 5 acres), while parcels in a transitional AG size (staff discussed a 5–10 acre band) would remain subject to special-permit review for farm-stay requirements.
Third, staff proposed replacing the ordinance’s ambiguous “10 nearest dwellings as the crow flies” concentration test with a proximity standard of 300 feet measured from the center of the dwelling used for the short-term rental; staff noted the change focuses review on immediate neighbors and reduces the odd results produced by the earlier language.
Commissioners debated intent and scope but broadly supported the changes as clarifications that reduce case-by-case inconsistency. Commissioner Mulder said changes prevent staff and commissioners from being put in the position of “picking and choosing” based on subjective impressions. Commissioner Levy and others said the special-permit pathway remains available for cases that need individualized review.
The commission moved, seconded and adopted the ordinance amendments by roll-call vote; staff will revise county code language and return the ordinance for any necessary next-legislative steps and finalization with the Board of Supervisors as applicable.
