Get Full Government Meeting Transcripts, Videos, & Alerts Forever!
Get email alerts on the Short Term Rentals topic
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Commission approves Mazzanti short-term rental special permit in Trinidad area 4–1
Summary
The planning commission granted a special permit allowing a short-term rental on Alder Lane in the Trinidad area despite neighborhood-concentration limits; commissioners cited road function, parking, safety and operator commitments in finding the permit compatible with the neighborhood.
The Humboldt County Planning Commission approved a special permit for a short-term rental at a property on Alder Lane in the Trinidad area, voting 4–1 on the staff recommendation.
Staff presenter Chris Loheff said the Mazzanti application met the county’s short-term rental checklist, including a Good Neighbor Guide, parking, water and septic arrangements, and safety measures such as fire and carbon-monoxide detectors. The application required a special permit because the neighborhood-concentration rule would be exceeded on the private access road: two existing permitted short-term rentals already put that access road at 50 percent; approval of the Mazzanti permit would raise the proportion to 75 percent.
Loheff described the access road, Alder Lane, as a narrow private road that nonetheless provides functional width and pullouts and is regularly maintained by one of the parcel owners. He recommended the commission find the road functions at the equivalent of the category 3 road standard in the ordinance and approve the special permit with conditions.
Applicants Ashley and Tim Mazzanti and a neighbor-supporter, Mike Reinman, spoke in favor; Ashley Mazzanti said the owners intend to occupy the house full time in the near future and are requesting the permit to support their transition. Tim Mazzanti and a local manager said the owners intend to be good neighbors and limit rentals to protect neighborhood character.
Commission debate touched on the ordinance’s intent to protect long-term housing stock and to limit concentration-driven noise and parking impacts. Commissioner O'Neil cast the sole “no” vote; Commissioners Mulder, Levy, Curiazzi and Chair Scavdahl supported approval.
Commissioner Mulder moved to adopt the staff resolution finding the project exempt from further environmental review under the state CEQA guidelines and to approve the special permit; Commissioner Levy seconded. Roll-call vote: O'Neil—no; Mulder—yes; Levy—yes; Curiazzi—yes; Scavdahl—yes. The motion carried 4–1.
The approved permit includes the operational conditions described in the staff report, and administrative permits for short-term rentals in the county are subject to renewal requirements and monitoring described in the ordinance.
